Swimming pools blog

get advice about heaters, pumps, filters, liners, chemicals and maintaining private swimming pools

Swimming pools blog header image 2


question for Mr. electricjet

March 19th, 2005 · 6 Comments

Hi
Yesterday the pool people came and closed my IG. Same folks that did it
last year.
Luckily my son went out in the poolhouse around 6pm tonight to retreive
his tapeplayer from upstairs and he heard hte filterrunning.
He came in and my husband ran down adn sure enough. The guys turned of
filter by the timer and never shut off the switch. The filter came on
this am at 8am.
I will call the pool company in the am let them know what happened and
tell them to make note of this. The filter is only 2 seasons old. How
long is a normal lifespan and do you this this damaged it? It a Hayward
1 1/2 HP. I was worried about the antifreeze and the lines being sucked
dry whatever… but husband says nothing got pumped because there was no
prime. What do you think? Thanks L:inda

Tags: pumps

6 responses so far ↓

  • 1 janis_40 // Mar 20, 2005 at 6:05 am

    Linda,
    You said it was a Hayward 1-1/2 hp pump. If it was one of their Super II
    pumps(the Super II has six bolts holding the sides together. They are arranged
    around the outside of the motor) then you are in luck. If you have not done
    anything to it as of now and the pump has no water or antifreeze in it then just
    wait until next spring when you open up the pool again. The Super II is a
    good pump in that it tolerates running dry better than most other brands so
    hopefully next spring the most you will need to do is replace the strainer
    basket
    and the pump seal. The pump seal is about a $15.00 part and the basket is a
    bit more. What may have happened is that the remaining water was turned to
    steam by the friction of the pump seal running without water to cool it. The
    steam is hot enough to melt the basket and crack the ceramic of the seal but if
    it was not run too long then the remaining parts should have survived. If you
    wish you could unscrew the cover of the pump and check the basket but it is

    best to wait until spring to do anything. Besides you cannot test the pump for
    leakage anyway because there is not any water in it. Next spring remove the
    pump basket and check if it is deformed. If it is not then put everything back
    together and prime the pump. If it does not leak under the motor then
    consider yourself lucky but be warned that if it does not leak now it will
    within a
    year or so.
    Ken
    In a message dated 10/2/2003 9:31:12 PM Central Daylight Time,
    Ldubois@… writes:
    Hi
    Yesterday the pool people came and closed my IG. Same folks that did it
    last year.
    Luckily my son went out in the poolhouse around 6pm tonight to retreive
    his tapeplayer from upstairs and he heard hte filterrunning.
    He came in and my husband ran down adn sure enough. The guys turned of
    filter by the timer and never shut off the switch. The filter came on
    this am at 8am.
    I will call the pool company in the am let them know what happened and
    tell them to make note of this. The filter is only 2 seasons old. How
    long is a normal lifespan and do you this this damaged it? It a Hayward
    1 1/2 HP. I was worried about the antifreeze and the lines being sucked
    dry whatever… but husband says nothing got pumped because there was no
    prime. What do you think? Thanks L:inda

  • 2 janis_40 // Mar 21, 2005 at 1:33 am

    In a message dated 10/3/2003 9:14:53 AM Central Daylight Time,
    kglosser@… writes:
    would not let this rest…….I would demand somebody with authority come
    over and troubleshoot the system NOW!!!….They will likely resist this,
    saying you have nothing to worry about..CONTACT THE HIGHEST
    I am not saying to let this rest but the down side is that they will need to
    open the pool again to test the system. The labor will be free but I do not
    think the company will pay for the water to refill the pool or the electric
    power needed to run the pump for several days. The pump may look Ok visually
    but
    in a week or a month it may start leaking. Testing it now may not find a
    problem and unless you replace the entire pump you will never be sure.
    One thing I did forget and I am sorry about this is that when a pump is run
    dry the heat not only melts the basket but can cause the PVC pipe attached to
    your pump to shrink causing the connections at the pump to leak. Again this is

    something that may not show up with a simple test but may show up a week or a
    month later. If you have them test it now and it is OK then they are off the
    hook for future problems.
    You need to get an agreement that they will repair problems with the pump
    related to running it dry for a period of six months or more. Be realistic and
    do not expect them to fix every thing that goes wrong with your system because
    if the motor dies that is not caused by running it dry but a pump seal leak
    is. If you need to replumb the pump it is not hard but I would use schedule 80
    PVC (grey) to do it. Just a short six to eight inch piece is fine. It will
    act as a heat sink in case this happens again.
    Ken

  • 3 janis_40 // Mar 25, 2005 at 2:56 am

    In a message dated 10/3/2003 1:30:56 PM Central Daylight Time,
    kglosser@… writes:
    Naturally, Ken makes sense on this….AT LEAST GET AN AGREEMENT IN WRITING…
    (but even “in writing” today does not guarantee “in business” next
    spring……..KEN, WHAT IS THE POTENTIAL DAMAGES IN DOLLARS VS. $50 WORTH OF
    WATER?????????????????
    In all reality if the pump is a Hayward Super II then it is probably just
    fine. Possibly a new pump seal and a new basket $40.00 plus labor and also the
    possibility that the pipes might leak $50.00 to fix. So if the pool company
    goes under during the winter then yes you are out but if you did the work
    yourself to fix the pump and pipes it would cost you maybe $60.00. So $100.00
    parts
    and labor vs. $50.00 in water and electricity. If they refill the pool and
    restart the system and leave it run for a day or two and everything is fine
    then what? Next spring the pump starts leaking after a month and the pool

    company says we settled last fall, then what? I think the certified letter
    idea is
    a good one. If the company has been in the area for many years then there is
    no reason to expect they will be gone this winter. If she is a good customer
    and the company wishes to retain her as a customer then they will fix the
    problem.
    Now if she had a Sta-Rite Duraglass then you couls pull the pump apart and
    see the damage. With the Hayward it is not that easy.
    Ken

  • 4 janis_40 // Mar 26, 2005 at 5:52 pm

    In a message dated 10/3/2003 6:28:01 PM Central Daylight Time,
    kglosser@… writes:
    Hey Ken….You love California pools…..I have a California Pool and they
    sold me a Hayward (which you don’t seem to like)
    Let us set the record straight. I like Hayward IG pumps the Super II and the
    Northstar, I like the Hayward DE and cartridge filters in that they are a
    good product but the material in the tanks could be better. I really do not
    like much of what Sta-Rite makes and the new Pentair company is a merger/buyout
    of many small pool companies including PacFab and Purex both of which have
    products I like. PacFab fiberglass filters are a rugged design and the Purex
    Whisperflow pump is great as well. These opinions were formed over years behind
    the service counter as a manager in the pool supply industry and dealing with
    companies getting warranty service.
    As far as what your dealer sold you it is not based entirely on what the
    dealer feels is the best product but who will give them the best price on

    equipment. If California Pools did not think Hayward was a good brand at a good
    price
    they would not sell it. I said I liked them because they are an old company
    who has stayed afloat in a sea of bankruptcy.
    Ken

  • 5 janis_40 // Mar 27, 2005 at 1:21 pm

    In a message dated 10/4/2003 8:22:48 AM Central Daylight Time,
    lwps16@… writes:
    I have to agree with Ken about the Hayward pumps, I sold five to
    customers at their request and two were bad straight out of the box,
    I prefer whisperflo when it comes to pumps. Sta-rites are decent,
    but don’t stand up to the torture of commercial pools, again, I
    choose whisperflo. only my opinion.
    What models of Hayward pumps did you sell? Only the Super II and the
    Northstar are good pumps. Do you have any opinion on Emerson motors. Several
    years
    ago when AO Smith aquired Magnatec many engineers jumped ship and Emerson
    picked them up in hopes of getting a bigger share of the pool market. Needless
    to say their initial efforts were less than stellar.
    Ken

  • 6 Earlene Haydee // Mar 27, 2005 at 9:50 pm

    Ken
    they were the super II’s, only they were not that super!

You must log in to post a comment.