Swimming pools blog

get advice about heaters, pumps, filters, liners, chemicals and maintaining private swimming pools

Swimming pools blog header image 2


Inground pool questions …

December 27th, 2004 · 1 Comment

Hi, I’m about to invest in a 12′x26′ inground pool - would like some
independent advice on the following.
1. gas heater or heat pump?
2. “in corner stairs” which are under the vinyl liner, or preformed
stairs?
3. use a hayward dual speed pump SP2610X152S and keep it on low
speed to maintain circulation/water temps, or go with single speed
and on/off switch when needed?
4. in terms of location, is it better to place deep end of pool
where the sun sets or is this strictly a preference?
5. automated chlorinator or new fangled ‘cartridges’ (”new water”?)
appreciate any insights … the dealers here each have their own
varying opinions making it difficult to decide/

Tags: heaters

1 response so far ↓

  • 1 janis_40 // Dec 28, 2004 at 7:11 am

    In a message dated 8/10/2003 5:01:53 PM Central Daylight Time,
    jmtashiro@… writes:
    You will find that no matter how many people you talk to all will never agree
    on everything.
    Gas heater or Heat pump - The initial investment on a gas heater is not
    nearly as expensive as heat pumps but depending on the price of gas in your area
    the heat pump might pay for itself in the long run. There are several things
    you need to consider before the choice is made. What part of the country are
    you in and do you intend to use the pool in the winter? The heat pump takes
    it’s heat from the ambient air and they are not very efficient when the air temp
    drops into the low 50’s so if you wanted to heat the pool in the winter the
    heat pump might require a backup heat source. The gas heater on the other hand
    just burns gas and will work anytime and how long it takes to heat the pool
    depends on the size of the heater and how cold the pool is to start with. In
    the middle of winter with a cold pool and lots of guests it is not unlikely you

    will burn several hundred dollars in gas over a long weekend. In either case
    a solar blanket works wonders in helping retain the heat in the pool. I saw a
    study by a heat pump manufacturer several years ago where they heated a pool
    year round and used over eight grand in gas for the year and about half that
    in electricity for their heat pumps. Of course it took two heat pumps to keep
    the pool warm in winter and by adding the solar blanket it cut the costs in
    half for both systems. With either system getting as much sun as you can on the
    pool all year round helps a great deal.
    I am not a real big fan of IG vinyl liner pools but anything that makes the
    liner more complicated will drive up the replacement costs down the road.
    The SP2610 is a Hayward Super Pump (JUNK)! Go with their Super II pump the
    3000 series as they are better built and more efficient. Stay away from the
    two speeds as well and go with a single speed with a time clock. The difference
    here is the type of filtration you are using rather than the pump. Go with
    the multi cartridge filter or if you really want to the DE filter but the DE is
    more work for just a small gain. Stay away from sand if your pool will be
    around an area that has a lot of vegetation as the sand cannot filter out the
    churned up particles of organic matter the pump sends through the system.
    As far as the deep end goes try and get the entire pool in the sun if you can
    and unless you are getting a diving board why do you need a deep end? A
    slide is much more fun for kids and only requires about four feet. A deep end
    of
    eight feet or more really adds to the gallonage of the pool and to your
    maintenance costs. It also might add in the insurance costs as well.
    If you are talking about one of the “Mineral Purification” systems that
    replaces much of the chlorine in the pool I would say yes to it but I am not
    familiar with that product as there are about a dozen or more names for the same
    type system. I am familiar with the Nature 2 or N2 system and combined with a
    chlorine generating system will make a your pool very maintenance free. Yes,
    the systems are a bit steep up front but in the long run I think you will be
    ahead in the fact you will use fewer chemicals in your pool. Remember the
    filtration system is 80% of keeping that pool clean and skimping on the system
    just
    means you will be spending more on chemicals which will make your dealer very
    happy.
    A great system for your pool would be a Hayward 1hp Super II and a 300 or 400
    square foot multi cartridge filter along with a pool cleaner and a mineral
    purification system and some type of chlorine generating system.
    Ken

You must log in to post a comment.